SFC Submits comments to US Copyright Office on Generative AI and Copyleft
We have responded to the Copyright Office's request for comments regarding machine learning and generative AI.
Our comments highlight how copyleft truly “promote[s] Progress in Science and the Useful Arts & that copyleft licensing should be specifically considered in any rulemaking or legislation. SFC drew specific attention to the questions regarding financial-focused “compulsory licensing”. SFC fears that, either through Congress or industry “self regulation”, compulsory licensing of software may become a tool to eviscerate copyleft.
Read more: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/nov/01/us-copyright-office-generative-ai-machine-learning/
https://sfconservancy.org/docs/2023-10-30_Software-Freedom-Conservancy-Copyright-Office-Generative-AI-Comments-Docket-2023-6.pdf
Our comments highlight how copyleft truly “promote[s] Progress in Science and the Useful Arts & that copyleft licensing should be specifically considered in any rulemaking or legislation. SFC drew specific attention to the questions regarding financial-focused “compulsory licensing”. SFC fears that, either through Congress or industry “self regulation”, compulsory licensing of software may become a tool to eviscerate copyleft.
Read more: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/nov/01/us-copyright-office-generative-ai-machine-learning/
https://sfconservancy.org/docs/2023-10-30_Software-Freedom-Conservancy-Copyright-Office-Generative-AI-Comments-Docket-2023-6.pdf
Our Director of Compliance has blogged about he watched it and some thoughts as well: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2023/oct/12/how-i-watched-motion-summary-judgment-hearing/
The transcript from the summary judgement hearing in our Vizio lawsuit has just been published. You can read about it here: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/oct/12/transcript-msj-hearing/
Question: What kind of insight do you feel like you have now into how your work or likeness is being used by generative AI systems, and what kind of transparency do you feel is needed?
Bradley: "...there is now no question that the body of copylefted FOSS is a huge part of the software-assisted development machine learning systems."
"...there is no reason that Big Tech shouldn't be regulated to make these systems transparent — end to end."
"...the public should have access to the input set, have access to the source code of the software that does the training and generation, and most importantly, access to the source code that does these forms of back-end exclusion..."
Bradley: "...there is now no question that the body of copylefted FOSS is a huge part of the software-assisted development machine learning systems."
"...there is no reason that Big Tech shouldn't be regulated to make these systems transparent — end to end."
"...the public should have access to the input set, have access to the source code of the software that does the training and generation, and most importantly, access to the source code that does these forms of back-end exclusion..."
Bradley's opening remarks: "I avoid using any proprietary software, but in this case, it is not merely esoteric principle"
"...every consumer deserves the right to examine how their software works, to modify, improve and change it — be it altruistically or commercially."
"For 30 years, our community has created FOSS and made it publicly available. Big Tech, for its part, continues to refuse to share most of its own software in the same way."
"Big Tech claims that the rules, licensing, and legislation that has applied to creative works since the 1800s in the United States are suddenly moot simply because machine learning is, in their view, too important to be bogged down by the licensing choices of human creators of works."
"...every consumer deserves the right to examine how their software works, to modify, improve and change it — be it altruistically or commercially."
"For 30 years, our community has created FOSS and made it publicly available. Big Tech, for its part, continues to refuse to share most of its own software in the same way."
"Big Tech claims that the rules, licensing, and legislation that has applied to creative works since the 1800s in the United States are suddenly moot simply because machine learning is, in their view, too important to be bogged down by the licensing choices of human creators of works."
Opening remarks from other panelists include thoughts about how to protect the labor and works of creative and other content creators, the need for public policy, and a refocus of the conversation on those affected by, not creating the generative systems.
As the FTC panel begins https://kvgo.com/ftc/Creative-Economy-and-Generative-AI-October-4-2023 we heard from FTC Commission Slaughter: "... copyright is not the only tool." to protect our labor and works.
Be sure to tune into the FTC panel about “Creative Economy and Generative AI” featuring @conservancy Policy Fellow Bradley M. Kuhn at 19:00 UTC
https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/oct/04/ftc-ai-panel/
https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/oct/04/ftc-ai-panel/
Our Policy Fellow Bradley M. Kuhn will be on the FTC round table discussion "Creative Economy and Generative AI" tomorrow. He's joining a panel of artists, policy makers, union organizers and other activists as the one to represent the FOSS and greater software communities. You can watch the webcast at 19:00 UTC: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events/2023/10/creative-economy-generative-ai
Our Policy Fellow Bradley M. Kuhn will be on the FTC round table discussion discussion "Creative Economy and Generative AI" tomorrow. He's joining a panel of artists, policy makers, union organizers and other activists as the one to represent the FOSS and greater software communities. You can watch the webcast at 19:00 UTC: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events/2023/10/creative-economy-generative-ai
@fell @anjan We just got the videos up! You can see our blog post here: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/sep/14/fossy-videos/
The FOSSY videos are up! Check out our blog post for more information here: https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/sep/14/fossy-videos/
Thanks to all our speakers, AV team, volunteers and sponsors for making FOSSY happen. We can't wait to do it again next year!
Thanks to all our speakers, AV team, volunteers and sponsors for making FOSSY happen. We can't wait to do it again next year!
Denver Gingerich, our Director of Compliance, was interviewed on @richlitt podcast SustainOSS at #FOSSY. A great listen if you want to learn about recent compliance developments at SFC and hear about some of Denver's other work. Thanks so much to Rich for bringing SustainOSS to #FOSSY https://podcast.sustainoss.org/195
We Call on FOSS Contributors to “Exit Zoom”!
After the recent change of the terms of service to Zoom, Software Freedom Conservancy seeks to bring light to corporate abuse of power and focus on making FOSS solutions to these proprietary requirements.
https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/aug/15/exit-zoom/
After the recent change of the terms of service to Zoom, Software Freedom Conservancy seeks to bring light to corporate abuse of power and focus on making FOSS solutions to these proprietary requirements.
https://sfconservancy.org/news/2023/aug/15/exit-zoom/
Our Director of Compliance discusses the Rust Foundation's (draft) trademark policy by looking at what we can learn from the sometimes too exciting history of software freedom trademark policies
https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2023/jul/27/trademark-history-and-rust/
https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2023/jul/27/trademark-history-and-rust/
The first video from #FOSSY is out! 🎉 If you have been following our writing, you know our Policy Fellow Bradley M. Kuhn wrote about the recent RHEL policy change. As a continuation of that discussion, he led a keynote panel at the conference to discuss the issue with representatives from AlmaLinux, Rocky Linux and Oracle.
You can view the video and more information here: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2023/jul/19/rhel-panel-fossy-2023/
You can view the video and more information here: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2023/jul/19/rhel-panel-fossy-2023/
@icedquinn It's marked as proprietary software with 🙅! Our speaker policy required speakers to label all proprietary software, and this one was no different.
Pono from @conservancy talks about how he used free software to plan his wedding at #FOSSY
No room for proprietary software here!
No room for proprietary software here!
